Uncontested vs. Contested Divorce: Pros and Cons in Orleans County, New York

Divorce is a challenging and emotional process, and the path you choose can significantly impact the outcome and the experience itself. Orleans County, New York, like many other regions, offers individuals the choice between two primary types of divorce: uncontested and contested. Each option has its pros and cons, which individuals considering divorce should carefully weigh. In this article, we will explore the key differences between uncontested and contested divorce in Orleans County and the advantages and disadvantages of each.Uncontested vs. Contested Divorce Pros and Cons in Orleans County New York

Uncontested Divorce

Uncontested divorce, also known as a no-fault divorce, is a straightforward and amicable way to end a marriage. In Orleans County, New York, an uncontested divorce is the preferred route, especially when both spouses can agree on the terms of their separation.

Pros of Uncontested Divorce

Saves Time and Money

Uncontested divorces are generally faster and less expensive compared to contested divorces. Since both spouses agree on key issues such as property division, child custody, and spousal support, there is no need for lengthy court battles.

Lower Emotional Stress

An uncontested divorce is typically less emotionally taxing. Spouses can work together, reducing conflict and animosity, which can be especially beneficial when children are involved.


This method allows couples to maintain a degree of privacy because there is no need for public court proceedings.

Control Over the Outcome

Both spouses have control over the terms of their divorce, making it more likely that the agreement will meet their individual needs and preferences.

Legal Support

Although an attorney is not required, many couples choose to consult with an attorney or mediator to ensure they understand their rights and that the agreement is legally sound.

Cons of Uncontested Divorce

Requires Cooperation: An uncontested divorce relies on both spouses’ willingness to work together and reach a compromise. If one party is uncooperative or refuses to agree on key issues, the process may need to transition to a contested divorce.

Limited Legal Protections: Without proper legal advice, one or both spouses may inadvertently agree to terms that are not in their best interests.

Contested Divorce

Contested divorce is the more traditional and adversarial approach to ending a marriage. It is often necessary when couples cannot reach an agreement on key issues, such as property division, child custody, and alimony.

Pros of Contested Divorce

Legal Protections: In contested divorces, each party has the opportunity to present their case in court and fight for their rights and interests. This can be essential when there is a significant power imbalance between spouses.

Third-Party Decision-Making: In cases of disagreement, a judge can make fair and impartial decisions, ensuring that the outcome is in the best interest of all parties, especially children.

Cons of Contested Divorce


Contested divorces tend to be much more time-consuming than uncontested ones, dragging on for months or even years. This can add significant stress and legal fees.


Legal fees can quickly mount in a contested divorce, especially when both parties hire attorneys, engage in lengthy court battles, and pay for expert witnesses.

Emotionally Draining

The adversarial nature of contested divorce often exacerbates emotional stress and can strain relationships with children and extended family members.

Public Proceedings

Court hearings and trials are typically public, which can result in a loss of privacy and the disclosure of sensitive information.

Uncertain Outcome

In a contested divorce, the outcome is in the hands of the court, making it challenging to predict the final resolution accurately.

Choosing between an uncontested and contested divorce in Orleans County, New York, ultimately depends on your unique circumstances. If you and your spouse can amicably agree on the terms of your separation, an uncontested divorce may be the most efficient and cost-effective option. However, if you face insurmountable differences, a contested divorce may be necessary to ensure that your rights and interests are protected, even if it comes at a higher emotional and financial cost.

Regardless of the path you choose, it is essential to consult with a qualified attorney in Orleans County to navigate the legal process smoothly and make informed decisions that align with your best interests and those of your family.

How can Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. help you on Divorce cases in New York

At the law firm of Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ., we are dedicated to providing comprehensive legal assistance to individuals facing divorce in New York. We understand that divorce can be a complex and emotionally challenging process, and we are here to help you navigate the legal aspects of your case while offering support and guidance every step of the way.

Legal Experience

Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. is an experienced attorney with a strong background in divorce and family law in New York. He possesses the knowledge and experience required to guide you through the legal complexities of divorce proceedings, ensuring that your rights are protected, and your interests are well-represented.

Customized Legal Strategies

We recognize that no two divorce cases are alike. Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. will work closely with you to understand your unique situation, goals, and concerns. With this insight, he can develop a tailored legal strategy that best suits your specific needs, whether you are pursuing an uncontested divorce or facing a contested divorce.

Negotiation and Mediation

Our firm is well-versed in negotiation and mediation techniques to help couples reach amicable agreements when possible. Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. can facilitate productive discussions and negotiations, aiming for fair and mutually satisfactory outcomes that save you time, money, and emotional distress.

Litigation Support

In cases where amicable resolution is not feasible, Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. is a zealous advocate in the courtroom. He will tirelessly represent your interests, protecting your rights during the divorce process, including matters related to child custody, spousal support, property division, and more.

Child Custody Matters

For divorcing couples with children, we understand the paramount importance of child custody and support arrangements. Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. is skilled in helping parents navigate the complexities of child custody laws in New York and will work to ensure the best interests of your children are prioritized.

Asset and Property Division

Dividing marital assets and property can be a contentious aspect of divorce. Our firm is well-equipped to help you negotiate, mediate, or litigate property division matters, aiming for an equitable distribution that reflects your financial interests.

Alimony and Spousal Support

We can assist in determining the appropriate amount of spousal support (alimony) you may be entitled to or required to pay, ensuring that the support arrangements are just and fair.

Emotional Support

We understand the emotional toll that divorce can take on individuals and families. Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. and our compassionate legal team offer support and guidance throughout the process, making the journey as smooth and manageable as possible.

Compliance with New York Laws

Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. is well-versed in New York’s divorce laws and regulations. He ensures that your case complies with all legal requirements and deadlines, allowing you to proceed with confidence.

If you are facing a divorce in New York, Michael D. Schmitt, ESQ. is here to provide the legal representation and guidance you need to navigate this challenging chapter in your life. We are committed to helping you achieve the best possible outcome while safeguarding your rights and interests. Contact our firm today to schedule a consultation and begin your journey toward a brighter future.

Leave a Reply